07 Jun Book Review: How to Raise an Elephant by Alexander McCall Smith

There’s something undeniably comforting about returning to the world of Mma Precious Ramotswe and her No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency. It’s like slipping into a familiar rhythm, much like the steady hum of cicadas on a warm Botswana evening. I first encountered this series during my university days in Brisbane, when the bustling city life had me yearning for tales set in more tranquil locales. McCall Smith’s depiction of Gaborone provided that serene escape, and diving into “How to Raise an Elephant,” the 21st installment, felt like a heartfelt reunion with old friends.​

What’s it about?

In this latest chapter of the No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency series, Mma Ramotswe finds herself navigating a series of interconnected events that test her wisdom, patience, and innate sense of justice. The narrative unfolds during a particularly sweltering period in Gaborone, where the oppressive heat seems to mirror the simmering challenges awaiting our beloved detective.​

The story begins with Mma Ramotswe being approached by a distant cousin, Blessing Mompati, who seeks financial assistance for a friend’s hip replacement surgery. Blessing’s plea is emotionally charged, painting a picture of desperation and urgency. However, Mma Ramotswe, ever the discerning detective, senses inconsistencies in the tale. Balancing the cultural expectation of aiding family with her detective instincts, she embarks on a subtle investigation to discern the truth behind Blessing’s request.​

Simultaneously, the agency’s part-time assistant, Charlie, borrows Mma Ramotswe’s cherished white van and returns it with minor damages and an unidentifiable earthy odor. Curiosity leads Mma Ramotswe and her associate, Mma Makutsi, to uncover that Charlie has been harboring an orphaned baby elephant in his modest backyard. This endearing yet precarious situation propels them into the complexities of wildlife conservation, ethical responsibilities, and the challenges of ensuring the calf’s safety.​

Amidst these events, Mma Ramotswe becomes attuned to the discordant arguments of her new neighbors. Their loud disputes disrupt the usual tranquility of the neighborhood, prompting Mma Ramotswe to reflect on the nature of relationships, communication, and the silent struggles that often lie beneath the surface.​

Throughout the novel, McCall Smith intricately weaves these narratives, allowing readers to meander through the contemplative and often humorous musings of Mma Ramotswe and her circle. The overarching themes delve into the essence of human connection, the moral intricacies of intervention, and the enduring quest for understanding in a rapidly evolving society.​

What This Chick Thinks

A Gentle Pace Reflecting Life’s Realities

Reading “How to Raise an Elephant” felt like taking a leisurely stroll through the familiar streets of Gaborone. McCall Smith’s unhurried narrative pace mirrors the day-to-day realities of its characters, emphasizing the beauty found in life’s simpler moments. While some readers might yearn for intricate plots or high-stakes drama, the charm of this series lies in its celebration of the ordinary. Mma Ramotswe’s reflections on life, love, and morality offer profound insights wrapped in everyday observations.​

Character Dynamics and Evolution

The evolving dynamics between characters, particularly between Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi, provide a rich tapestry of friendship and professional camaraderie. Their dialogues, often laced with humor and differing perspectives, highlight the complexities of human relationships. Charlie’s subplot with the baby elephant adds a layer of youthful impulsiveness contrasted against Mma Ramotswe’s measured wisdom, showcasing the generational shifts and challenges within the community.​

Subtle Social Commentary

McCall Smith seamlessly integrates subtle social commentaries, addressing issues such as familial obligations, ethical dilemmas in wildlife conservation, and the impact of modernization on traditional values. These themes are explored with a light touch, prompting reflection without veering into didacticism.​

A Few Quibbles

While the novel offers much to savor, there are moments where the plot meanders, and certain resolutions feel a tad too convenient. The detective work, which initially drew me to the series, takes a backseat in this installment, making way for more personal narratives. While this shift isn’t unwelcome, a balance between the two would have enriched the reading experience further.​

Final Thoughts

“How to Raise an Elephant” is a heartwarming addition to the No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency series, offering readers a contemplative journey through the lives of its endearing characters. McCall Smith’s affectionate portrayal of Botswana and his nuanced exploration of human nature make this novel a comforting read. While it may not be the most plot-driven installment, its charm lies in its gentle storytelling and the profound simplicity of its narrative. I’d rate it an 8 out of 10.​

Try it if you like:

• “The Number One Chinese Restaurant” by Lillian Li
  An exploration of family dynamics and the complexities of running a family business, set against the backdrop of a bustling restaurant.​
• “The Readers of Broken Wheel Recommend” by Katarina Bivald
  A tale of a Swedish woman who finds herself in a small American town, discovering the transformative power of books and community.​
• “The No. 2 Feline Detective Agency” by Mandy Morton
  A whimsical mystery series featuring feline detectives, blending charm, humor, and intrigue in equal measure.