14 Jun Book Review: Defy Me by Tahereh Mafi
After the emotional crescendo of Ignite Me and the political upheaval in Restore Me, I found myself eager to see where Juliette’s journey would lead next. Defy Me promised revelations and deeper dives into the characters’ psyches, and it did not disappoint. Reading this during a quiet weekend, I was reminded of times when confronting the past was the only way forward—a theme that resonates deeply in this installment.
‘Shatter Me’ series
What’s it about?
Defy Me picks up in the aftermath of the shocking events of Restore Me. Juliette Ferrars—now revealed to be Ella Sommers—is being held captive by her own parents, Supreme Commanders Max and Evie. They aren’t just indifferent rulers, but calculated manipulators who plan to erase Juliette’s memories and reprogram her into the perfect soldier once more. The twist? They’ve done this before. The Juliette we’ve come to know has been carefully shaped, not just by trauma but by deliberate design. Her mind, her identity, even her powers, have been controlled and conditioned.
She wakes up disoriented, subjected to psychological manipulation and pharmaceutical suppression. The girl who once feared her own skin now fears losing her very sense of self. And worse—her memories are starting to return. Snippets of a childhood spent in isolation, of training alongside a boy named Aaron, of the deep connection they shared before it was all torn away.
Meanwhile, Warner—Aaron Warner—is also being held against his will, tortured both mentally and emotionally. His captors aren’t physically harming him, but the forced unraveling of his past is its own torment. As he begins to remember his connection to Juliette/Ella, he is consumed by guilt for having withheld so much from her. Their relationship, once their anchor, now hangs by a thread as secrets spill faster than trust can catch them.
Back at Omega Point, Kenji Kishimoto is losing his mind. His best friend has vanished, his team is splintering, and no one is giving him answers. When Nazeera Ibrahim reenters the picture, she reluctantly becomes Kenji’s ally. She knows more than she’s letting on—including the truth about Juliette’s origins and the larger political game at play—but she’s not ready to bare it all. The tension between the two of them is electric—not romantic (yet), but emotionally charged in a way that makes every conversation a sparring match.
Eventually, the team reunites, but things are far from okay. Juliette and Warner are both reeling from what they’ve learned about their pasts—and each other. Their relationship has always been intense, but now it’s brittle. Trust has been fractured, and while their love remains, it’s buried beneath layers of confusion and betrayal.
The novel’s climax hinges less on external warfare and more on emotional reconciliation. This is a book about rebuilding—memory, identity, and love. It’s about facing the raw truth of who you are, who made you that way, and whether or not you can still choose something different. By the final pages, Juliette and Warner stand united, not because their pain is resolved, but because they finally understand its origins. The past doesn’t control them anymore. And with that knowledge, they’re ready to take on whatever’s next.
What This Chick Thinks
Intimate and Internal
Unlike the previous books, which focused on external revolutions and political strategy, Defy Me zooms way in. It’s an emotionally intimate novel, filled with flashbacks, inner monologues, and deeply personal reckonings. If you’re looking for action-heavy scenes or sweeping battles, this might feel like a slow burn—but if you love character development (like I do), this hits just right.
The Memory Unraveling Works
Sometimes amnesia and recovered memory arcs can feel cheap or convenient. Not here. Mafi has spent enough time building the emotional groundwork that these revelations feel earned. Watching Juliette remember—not just her trauma, but moments of joy and connection—adds layers to everything we’ve already read. It reframes so much.
Kenji Steals the Show (Again)
Can we just have a spin-off series called Kenji Saves the World? Please? His grief, frustration, and determination to keep everyone afloat while also falling apart himself is honestly one of the most relatable arcs in the series. And his dynamic with Nazeera? I’m rooting for it, whether or not it turns romantic.
It’s a Setup Book, But a Necessary One
Yes, this feels like a bridge novel. A lot of pieces are moved into place for the finale. But it doesn’t feel like filler. It feels like emotional prep work. Like cleaning the slate so that the final showdown actually means something.
Final Thoughts
Defy Me is all about peeling back layers—of memory, of relationships, of trust. It’s quieter and more reflective than the earlier books, but no less important. It does the hard work of emotional storytelling, and while it may not satisfy readers looking for action-heavy plotlines, it deeply rewards anyone invested in Juliette and Warner’s emotional journey.
Rating: 8/10
Try it if you like:
- Matched by Ally Condie – A dystopian romance where identity and control are central themes.
- An Ember in the Ashes by Sabaa Tahir – A story full of rebellion, identity loss, and complicated loyalties.
- Shadows and Lies by Eden Butler – For another emotionally intense story of power, memory, and uncovering the truth.
No Comments