18 Nov Book Review: Broken Harbor by Tana French

Tana French’s Broken Harbor is the fourth installment in her Dublin Murder Squad series, and it’s a masterclass in psychological suspense. Set against the backdrop of Ireland’s post-recession ghost estates, this novel delves deep into the unraveling of a seemingly perfect family and the detective tasked with uncovering the truth. French’s narrative is both haunting and immersive, making it a standout in contemporary crime fiction.

What’s it about?

Detective Mick “Scorcher” Kennedy, known for his high solve rate and adherence to procedure, is assigned a harrowing case in a half-abandoned housing development called Brianstown, formerly known as Broken Harbor. The Spain family—father Patrick, mother Jenny, and their two young children—have been brutally attacked. Patrick and the children are dead, and Jenny is in critical condition.

At first glance, the case appears to be a tragic murder-suicide, possibly driven by the economic downturn that left many, including the Spains, in dire straits. However, as Scorcher and his rookie partner, Richie Curran, delve deeper, unsettling details emerge: holes punched into the walls, baby monitors set up throughout the house, and erased computer files. Jenny had confided in her sister about a mysterious intruder, but there’s no evidence of a break-in.

As the investigation progresses, Scorcher is forced to confront his own past. Broken Harbor holds painful memories from his childhood, and the case begins to blur the lines between his professional and personal life. His sister, Dina, becomes increasingly unstable, dredging up family traumas that Scorcher has long tried to suppress.

The narrative intricately weaves the unraveling of the Spain family with Scorcher’s internal struggles. The pristine facade of the Spains’ life masks deep-seated fears and obsessions, mirroring the detective’s own need for control and order. As the case reaches its climax, Scorcher must navigate a labyrinth of psychological complexities, leading to a resolution that is as devastating as it is inevitable.

What This Chick Thinks

A Haunting Atmosphere

French masterfully captures the eerie desolation of the ghost estate, making the setting a character in its own right. The abandoned homes and unfinished developments serve as a stark backdrop to the unraveling of both the Spain family and Scorcher himself.

Deep Psychological Insight

The novel isn’t just a whodunit; it’s a profound exploration of the human psyche. French delves into themes of obsession, control, and the fragility of the mind, crafting characters that are deeply flawed yet achingly human.

Complex Character Dynamics

The relationship between Scorcher and Richie adds depth to the narrative. Their differing approaches to the case highlight generational and philosophical divides, enriching the story beyond the central mystery.

A Slow-Burning Narrative

While the novel’s pacing is deliberate, it allows for a thorough exploration of character and setting. The tension builds gradually, culminating in a climax that is both shocking and emotionally resonant.

Final Thoughts

Broken Harbor is a compelling blend of psychological thriller and police procedural. French’s nuanced storytelling and richly drawn characters make for a gripping read that lingers long after the final page. It’s a testament to her skill that she can craft a mystery that is as emotionally affecting as it is suspenseful.

Rating: 9/10

Try it if you like:

• The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins – A psychological thriller that delves into the complexities of memory and perception.
• In the Woods by Tana French – The first in the Dublin Murder Squad series, offering a similarly haunting and character-driven narrative.
• The Silent Corner by Dean Koontz – A suspenseful tale featuring a strong protagonist grappling with personal demons amidst a gripping mystery.